In one of the most popular sub-forums on the online platform Reddit, users ask each other for advice: Am I an asshole because I don't want to wear a bra to my best friend's wedding? Or want to tell my 14 year old daughter that she's just pretty average looking? These are just two of the thousands of questions that users post in the so-called “Am I the asshole” subreddit. In good moments, the website there is still what the entire Internet once wanted to be: a playground for free spirits who exchange ideas about God and the world.